Supper Clubs
Listings and reviews of our favorite Wisconsin Supper Clubs by region
Filter by Region
William Pine Gables
The ambiance delivers a cozy, Northwoods charm that feels both nostalgic and thoughtfully updated. It’s a comfortable and inviting space, perfect for a supper club experience.
The Twilight Supper Club
Twilight Supper Club strives to recreate the charm of a classic 1940s supper club. With a menu built around signature dishes timeless favorites, and its expertly crafted cocktails.
White Stag Inn
For an especially memorable experience, try to secure a seat by the indoor grill and be treated to the delicious aromas wafting from the grill as your meal being expertly prepared right before your eyes.
Pub N' Prime
A true northwoods supper club experience, Pub N' Prime blends classic Wisconsin charm with top-tier food and service.
Asana Suka
Formerly known as Redman Lounge, this delightful gem has quickly become our favorite of the local supper clubs in the charming Land O' Lakes area. ce.
Lanny’s Fireside Supper Club
You can’t miss Lanny’s Fireside along Highway 45, a charming restaurant with German-inspired dishes and exceptional service. Lanny’s has closed and is up for sale.
Turn Key Supper Club
Turn Key Supper Club offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for a laid-back dining experience.A unique touch is the cocktail menu, which can be found inside the Turn Key novels located at each table.
Green Lantern Restaurant
Located along the scenic shores of Lake Waubesa, and is a great location for boating enthusiasts offering spacious indoor dining, along with outdoor seating options perfect for enjoying cocktails while taking in the views of the lake.
Maple Tree Supper Club
The Maple Tree Supper Club is a classic diner-style establishment that prides itself on offering great food at reasonable prices in a relaxed, no-frills atmosphere. It's an ideal spot for those craving a traditional supper club experience with a friendly bar and flowing cocktails.
The Hilltop
The Hilltop features weekly specials, including their popular Wednesday and Friday Fish Fry. Enjoy classic supper club sides like baked, scalloped, or French fried potatoes, and a daily vegetable. Don't miss the standout relish tray appetizer. The menu also offers expertly prepared meats such as steaks, chicken, prime rib, and walleye.
Toby’s Supper Club
Toby's Supper Club, a Madison favorite, captures the essence of a classic, no-frills supper club experience. Known for its timeless charm and welcoming atmosphere, Toby's frequently draws crowds, especially on weekends, thanks to its loyal patrons and the reputation it has built over the years.
The Del Bar
The Del Bar offers a timeless dining experience with a blend of classic charm and upscale elegance. Located in the heart of Wisconsin Dells, it’s the perfect spot for those looking to indulge in a special evening, whether it's for a milestone celebration or simply treating yourself to a refined dining experience.
Cimaroli's Supper Club
Located a bit off the beaten path, this restaurant offers a surprisingly modern experience for those seeking a great meal. While it’s not the traditional supper club you might expect, it’s a fantastic spot for anyone looking for quality food in a sleek, updated setting.
Two Lakes Supper Club
This supper club truly embodies the charm of old-school dining, from the traditional decor with low lighting to the classic table settings. The venue offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere that feels both nostalgic and timeless. It's the perfect spot to enjoy a relaxed evening with great food and drinks.
Ishnala Supper Club
Ishnala Supper Club in Wisconsin Dells offers a unique North Woods dining experience. Tucked away in the forest, the scenic approach leads to a beautiful property with gardens and a beachfront on Mirror Lake. Despite potentially long waits, the charming ambiance makes it worthwhile.
The Bear Trap Inn
The Bear Trap Inn offers a quintessential Northwoods supper club experience in Land O' Lakes, WI, renowned for its classic steaks, seafood, and a beloved Friday night fish fry. Step into this charming institution to enjoy timeless Wisconsin hospitality and delicious, hearty meals in a welcoming atmosphere.