Cimaroli's Supper Club
Review
Home of the Flat Iron Steak and the $4 Old Fashioned
Located a bit off the beaten path, this restaurant offers a surprisingly modern experience for those seeking a great meal. While it’s not the traditional supper club you might expect, it’s a fantastic spot for anyone looking for quality food in a sleek, updated setting. The interior is contemporary, featuring expansive bar seating and a fresh, inviting atmosphere that sets it apart from more classic supper club vibes.
Ambiance:
Unlike many traditional supper clubs, the restaurant has an updated, modern feel with sleek furnishings and expansive bar seating. The vibe is more contemporary, making it a great spot for casual dining without the typical nostalgic decor found in more traditional supper clubs. Despite being in a relatively remote area, the interior is a pleasant surprise for those who appreciate a modern dining space.
Salad and Relish Tray:
This location doesn’t feature a salad bar or relish tray, which might be a drawback for those looking for those classic touches, but it does offer a choice of potatoes to accompany your meal. You can also add a soup or salad to your dish if desired, providing a little flexibility with your meal.
Drinks:
One of the standout features of this restaurant is their $4 Old Fashioned, which is a steal in terms of both quality and price. The well-made Old Fashioned is a perfect balance of flavors, offering a satisfying and classic cocktail at an unbeatable price. For anyone who enjoys a good Old Fashioned, this is definitely the drink to try.
Meal:
For the main course, we went with the simmering flat iron steak, which is delivered hot and sizzling to the table—an impressive and dramatic presentation. The steak is one of the best I’ve had, and certainly the best flat iron steak in Wisconsin, both in terms of meat quality and preparation. The steak was cooked to perfection, juicy, and tender, making it a standout dish. It comes with a choice of potato, and while you can add a soup or salad, the main event here is definitely the steak. For anyone who enjoys a good steak, this is a must-try.
Service:
The service here is efficient and friendly, making the entire dining experience smooth and enjoyable. The staff is attentive without being overbearing, ensuring that everything from the drinks to the meal arrives at the table in a timely manner.
Final Thoughts:
While this restaurant may not follow the traditional supper club format, it delivers exceptional food, particularly in the form of its simmering flat iron steak, which stands out as one of the best I’ve had in Wisconsin. The modern, updated ambiance and the unbeatable price of the Old Fashioned make this a great spot for anyone looking to enjoy a delicious, high-quality meal in a contemporary setting. Efficient service and a solid drink selection further enhance the experience. If you’re in the area and craving a great steak, this is definitely a place worth stopping by.
