Toby’s Supper Club
Review
Toby's Supper Club, a Madison favorite, captures the essence of a classic, no-frills supper club experience. Known for its timeless charm and welcoming atmosphere, Toby's frequently draws crowds, especially on weekends, thanks to its loyal patrons and the reputation it has built over the years.
Ambiance:
From the moment you step inside, Toby's exudes traditional supper club vibes. Guests can order their meals while enjoying a drink at the expansive wraparound bar, which serves as a great starting point before settling into the cozy, old-school seating area. The atmosphere is relaxed but vibrant, making it the perfect place for a casual night out.
Salad and Relish Tray:
Though there isn’t a salad bar, most meals come with a simple, fresh salad to start, offering a satisfying beginning to the meal. Toby’s also serves a classic relish tray, featuring a variety of fresh vegetables that pair well with the meal.
Drinks:
Toby's drink offerings are a major highlight:
The Key Lime Pie Martini stands out as a sweet, tangy, and refreshing house special that provides a fun twist on a traditional cocktail.
The Old Fashioneds, reasonably priced and well-crafted, are another crowd favorite, and they’re a staple at this supper club.
Menu:
Toby’s menu features classic supper club fare, with an emphasis on steak, seafood, and other beloved dishes. Notable fan favorites include:
5-piece breaded jumbo shrimp, which are always a hit.
The Toby’s Special top sirloin, served with onions and mushrooms, is another standout.
The Friday Fish Fry is legendary, offering crispy fish that keeps diners coming back for more.
Each entrée comes with a choice of soup or salad, a potato, and dinner rolls, ensuring a hearty and satisfying meal. A guest favorite side dish is the crispy hashbrowns with cheese and onions, which consistently receives rave reviews. During Friday Fish Fry’s you can end your meal with warm, mouth watering cinnamon rolls.
Service:
The service at Toby’s is quick and efficient, even during the busiest times. The friendly staff provides a welcoming atmosphere, and regulars are often greeted by name, adding to the sense of community.
Final Thoughts:
Toby's Supper Club continues to be a staple in Madison thanks to its welcoming ambiance, classic dishes, and attention to detail. The combination of great food, refreshing drinks, and outstanding service ensures that every visit feels special. Whether you’re enjoying the famous fish fry or a classic Old Fashioned, Toby’s offers a memorable supper club experience that keeps patrons returning time and time again.
Things To Do
See Things To Do - Southern Wisconsin (Madison)
